Lostaglio was the most productive hitter for the Hawks in their two SUNYAC Tournament games, batting 5-for-8 (.625) with six RBI. As a result, he was named to the All-Tournament Team at the 2013 SUNYAC Baseball Championship Tournament. In Friday's opening round loss to SUNY Oswego, he went 3-for-4 with three RBI and a double that helped the Hawks cut a 6-0 deficit to just a run. Lostaglio opened Saturday's matchup with SUNY Fredonia with a three-run homerun in the first inning, which was his first of the year. He hit 2-for-4 in the loss with three RBI and a run scored. He finishes the season leading the Hawks in batting average (.341), doubles (7), triples (2), RBI (20) and slugging percentage (.512). New Paltz (16-19, 12-6 SUNYAC) enjoyed the most successful in-conference record in the program's history and reached the SUNYAC Tournament for the second time in three years.